This exam paper explores historical perspectives and ethical considerations. Section A examines “The Life of P. T. Barnum“ by Phineas T. Barnum and “Why does the new film about P. T. Barnum gloss over his cruelty and racism?“ by Jane Fryer, focusing on contrasting views of Barnum′s achievements. Section B invites candidates to write either a talk about someone they strongly admire or dislike, or a letter detailing a difficult decision, emphasizing persuasive and reflective writing. Total marks: 80, balanced between analytical comparison and expressive composition.